Culture | Transatlantic histories

As Europeans went west, indigenous people travelled the other way

Caroline Dodds Pennock remembers their stories and impact in “On Savage Shores”

The Imprisonment of Guatimocin by the Troops of Hernan Cortes, 1856 (oil on canvas) (Photo by Art Images via Getty Images)
Strange meetingsImage: Getty Images

In recent decades indigenous people around the world have fought to rebuild cultures wrecked by colonialism, invoking a common phrase: “We are still here.” From protests against oil pipelines to bids to reclaim land, and from the revival of native cuisines to indigenous stories on screen, a renaissance is refuting the tired view that these cultures are vanishing.

According to Caroline Dodds Pennock’s absorbing account of indigenous peoples in 16th-century Europe, their roles in earlier history have been simplified or erased, too. “On Savage Shores” shatters the Eurocentric assumption that, half a millennium ago, people and ideas flowed in only one direction, from the old world to the “new”. Her study painstakingly reconstructs the first century of contact between colonial powers and the peoples of the Americas, documenting thousands of natives who travelled east, often involuntarily, to a continent they considered no less “savage” than the conquistadors had found their own.

This article appeared in the Culture section of the print edition under the headline "Return of the natives"

Big, green and mean

From the February 4th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Culture

Is this the greatest ever Premier League season?

The race between Manchester City, Arsenal and Liverpool masks issues at the bottom of the table

Romantasy brings dragons and eroticism together. At last

Novels starring hot fairies are selling millions of copies


Who’s afraid of Judith Butler, the “godmother of queer theory”?

A new book highlights Judith Butler’s fierceness and blind spots